Elective Practical Experiences—Choose Eight (8)
The new lawyer should also choose and complete at least 8 other experiences from the list below. These experiences do not necessarily need to be completed with the mentor. However, the new attorney should choose activities they wish to discuss with their mentor to receive guidance and feedback on how to handle similar situations in the future. New attorneys may choose from the more general list or may also choose from the area specific lists which more closely align with work realities or areas of interest. In cases where the mentor lacks expertise in a new attorney’s areas of interest, this would be a good opportunity to invite attorneys from your network with the desired expertise to attend your mentor meetings. A list of activities is listed below. They are broken into general and area specific. Again, this list is not exhaustive. New attorneys may count other activities they have performed which are not listed below. Approval of activities is not needed if they are substantially similar to activities listed. Novel or niche activities should be submitted to the NLTP Administrator (mentoring@utahbar.org) for approval.
General Activities –
- Participate in drafting a fee agreement for a client.
- Participate in a deposition of a witness or adverse party in a civil action.
- Participate in a trial in a civil or criminal case in either a state or federal court.
- Participate in an evidentiary hearing in a state or federal court.
- Observe or participate in mediation or arbitration.
- Observe or participate in a negotiation and explain relevant background context.
- Participate in the interviewing of a client.
- Participate in the counseling of a client.
- Prepare a complaint and a summons.
- Participate in trial preparation and observe or participate in a trial.
- Participate in or observe an appellate argument in the Utah Supreme Court, Utah Court of Appeals or in a Federal Appellate Court.
- Participate in plea negotiations or reviewing a plea agreement.
- Participate in drafting and reviewing wills and revocable living trusts.
- Participate in drafting and reviewing initial probate documents.
- Participate in forming business entities by drafting and reviewing incorporation documents and business agreements.
- Participate in preparing settlement documents, including a discussion of any tax implications in a settlement including a monetary award.
- Participate in an administrative hearing.
- Participate in drafting, amending, or reviewing a contract.
- Participate in drafting a pleading or motion for an administrative body or a state or federal court.
Area Specific Activities –
Administrative Law
Advocacy and Litigation
- Attend an appellate argument in the Utah Supreme Court, the Utah Court of Appeals, or a United States Circuit Court of Appeals;
- Attend or participate in a hearing on a motion; discuss.
- Attend or participate in an oral argument; discuss.
- Attend or participate in a trial, including voir dire if a jury trial; discuss.
- Discuss frequent issues that arise in litigation concerning specific Rules of Civil Procedure, and the local rules that apply in either state or federal court.
- Participate in 26(f) conference to discuss settlement, discovery plan and initial disclosures.
- Discuss the mechanics of trial, including where to stand, proper attire, when to stand, courtroom decorum, judges’ bench books, etc.
- Participate in drafting discovery requests, including interrogatories, requests for admission and requests for production of documents.
- Participate in preparing for and observing (or taking or defending) depositions.
Alternative Dispute Resolution
- Review and discuss Utah statutes on mediation including requirement to screen for potential conflict of interest of mediator.
- Observe, participate in, or prepare for an actual or simulated mediation.
- Observe, participate in, or prepare for, an arbitration and review and discuss AAA rules.
- Discuss how to prepare a client for mediation or arbitration.
Antitrust Law
Bankruptcy
- Participate in bankruptcy client intake.
- Counsel bankruptcy clients on options.
- Participate in bankruptcy 341 Hearing.
- Participate in bankruptcy confirmation hearing.
- Prep Petition, Schedules & SOFA.
- Attend 341 Hearing
- Prep reaffirmation agreement.
- Prep Non-dischargeability complaint.
- Prep relief from stay motion.
- Attend relief from stay hearing.
- Prep Chapter 13 plan.
- Review and discuss the different types of relief available under the Bankruptcy Code including Chapters 7 & 13.
- Complete the following activities related to Chapter 7:
- Interview Client.
- Gather needed documents and prepare filing.
- Attend 341(a) meeting of creditors.
- Complete the following activities related to Chapter 13:
- Interview Client.
- Gather documents and prepare filing.
- Prepare and file Chapter 13 plan.
- Attend and participate in 341(a) meeting of creditors.
- Attend Confirmation Hearing.
- Participate in preparing a Proof of Claim.
- Participate in preparing, or responding to, a motion for relief from the automatic stay.
- Draft complaint to commence an adversary proceeding.
- Participate in a hearing before the bankruptcy court regarding on outstanding motion.
- Assist in the preparation of a motion to employ under 11 U.S.C. § 327.
- Review and discuss disclosure of attorney compensation for debtor under 11 U.S.C. § 329 and Fed. R. Bankr. P. 2016.
- Draft a motion for examination under Fed. R. Bankr. P. 2004.
- Prepare and File a Motion to Abate.
- Prepare and File a Motion to Retain Taxes.
- Attend/Participate in a 341 Hearing.
- Attend/Participate in a Confirmation Hearing.
Business Law
- Participate in forming business entities by drafting and reviewing at least three of the following:
- Bylaws.
- Articles of incorporation.
- Articles of organization.
- Operating agreements.
- Partnership agreements.
- Corporate minutes and resolutions.
- Participate in drafting and reviewing at least three of the following:
- Shareholders’ agreements.
- Buy-sell agreements.
- Stock purchase agreements.
- Asset purchase agreements.
- Noncompetition agreements.
- Security/collateral agreements.
- Promissory notes.
- Participate in the due diligence process for mergers and acquisitions.
- Prepare UCC filings.
Civil Procedure
- Prepare complaint.
- Prepare summons.
- Cause summons to be served.
- Participate in preparing a Rule 12 motion to dismiss.
- Participate in preparing answer to complaint, counterclaim, cross-claim and third-party complaint.
- Participate in 26(f) conference to discuss settlement, discovery plan and initial disclosures.
- Participate in preparing initial disclosures as required by Rule 26.
- Participate in preparing for and observing, taking, or defending a deposition.
- Participate in drafting discovery requests, including interrogatories, requests for admission and requests for production of documents.
- Participate in identifying expert witnesses and producing expert witness reports.
- Participate in depositions including the deposition of expert witnesses.
- Participate in preparing motions and memoranda in support of summary judgment.
- Participate in preparing a pretrial order and making pretrial disclosures of witnesses and exhibits.
Client Interviewing and Counseling
- Discuss and review interview techniques (asking the right questions).
- Discuss and review counseling techniques (providing hard advice).
- Simulate and discuss the counseling of a client (mentor and new lawyer should alternate being client and lawyer).
- Participate in interviewing a client.
- Participate in counseling a client.
Constitutional Law
Construction
- Discuss Mechanic Lien laws.
- Discuss mechanics of a lien foreclosure.
- Dealing with the Lien Recovery Fund.
- Review and Discuss OSHA/Utah Labor Divisions.
- Attend Utah General Contractors Association Functions.
Contracts
- Negotiate a revenue contract.
- Draft Contract Amendment.
- Become familiar with Contract Management software, such as ORACLE.
- Translate contract language into Spanish and Portuguese.
- Participate in analyzing, interpreting and advising the legal effect of contract language.
- Draft amendments to employment contracts.
- Review real property leases.
- Participate in process of entering into a new credit agreement and associated due diligence.
- Draft an Independent Contractor Agreement.
- Draft a Non-Disclosure Provision/Agreement.
- Draft an Enforceable Non-Competition Clause.
- Review & Edit Customer Contracts for Company.
- Review Consumer Protection Laws in Various States and Update Contracts to Comply Prepare Settlement Agreement & Release.
- Draft a contract.
- Draft a complaint for breach of contract.
- Draft a private placement memorandum.
- Prepare a rescission offer.
Copyright Law
- Register a copyrighted work with the U.S. Copyright Office.
- Perform a fair use analysis for 10+ uses of copyrighted content in various media and settings.
- Negotiate a license for use of a copyrighted work.
- Examine uses of licensed copyrighted works for compliance with their respective licenses.
- Counsel a client on responsible uses of copyrighted works and on the risks/benefits of various approaches.
- Train client/client employees on copyright basics and tools.
Corporate Governance
- Review committee charters for NYSE compliance.
- Check Each Selected Item Draft memos to Board re: corporate governance-related issues, i.e. Dodd-Frank Act.
- Participate in Sarbanes-Oxley compliance for Corporate Governance.
Criminal Defense
- Review five different kinds of filed criminal cases and the charges that have been filed. Review the cited statutes, the allegations, and the related police reports. Review any arrest and search warrants filed in connection with the case and the charges. Discuss with mentor the elements of the offenses and the related alleged facts.
- Participate in the filing of case initiation documents, including the entry of appearance, request for discovery, and case file opening procedures.
- Participate in trial preparation. Required Learn and discuss with the mentor a prosecutor’s disclosure requirements under Rule 16, URCrP, Brady requirements and other applicable discovery rules and law.
- Review the reciprocal discovery rules for the defense and discuss with the mentor when and why reciprocal discovery should be provided.
- Attend an oral argument in open court.
- Participate in at least one trials criminal cases in either a state or federal court (preferably a case for which a jury verdict is reached).
- Participate in an evidentiary hearing in a state or federal court.
- Observe or participate in a plea negotiation.
- Explain relevant background and context and prepare or review a plea agreement.
- Participate in the interviewing of a witness.
- Participate in the interviewing of a defendant.
- Prepare or participate in the preparation of voir dire for a misdemeanor or a felony case.
- Prepare or review a Statement of Defendant to be used in entry of a guilty plea in both a misdemeanor and a felony case.
- Review and become familiar with Rule 11, URCrP and Rule 11 Fed.R.Cr.P.
- Review and understand Protective Orders including both civil protective orders under Chapter 7 of Title 78B and criminal protective orders under §77-36-2.5.
- Review the penalties for violations of both.
- Prepare a dispositive defense motion (e.g. Motion to Suppress Evidence).
- Become familiar with the Crime Victims’ Bill of Rights and the Rape Shield Statute and related Rules of Evidence regarding victims of sexual assaults and child molestation. (U.R.E. & F.R.E. 413 and 414, U.R.E. 404(c)).
- Crime Scene Viewing: Visit at least two crime scenes, preferably with an investigator, with regard to an active case. Required
Criminal Procedure
- Participate in client interview.
- Participate in charge negotiations with prosecutor’s office.
- Participate in discovery demands on prosecutor, including request for exculpatory materials.
- Participate in engagement of private investigator to interview witnesses.
- Review information or indictment for constitutional and/or pleading defects.
- Research elements of crime charged or under investigation; discuss.
- Review and discuss pretrial diversion requirements.
- Review and discuss plea in abeyance statute in a particular case and study applicable statute.
- Review and discuss criteria for a one- or two-level reduction of offense in a particular case and study applicable statute.
- Participate in discussions with Pretrial Services (bail).
- Participate in editing Statement by Defendant in Advance of Plea.
- Observe and/or participate in trial.
- Observe and/or participate in entry of plea in court.
- Review and discuss Presentence Report; participate in filing objections.
- Research and participate in analysis of federal sentencing guidelines in particular federal case.
Employment Law
- Review and discuss the UALD/EEOC administrative process. Review or participate in drafting a charge or the response to a charge.
- Prepare for and participate in the UALD/EEOC administrative process, including a resolutions conference or an appeal to the Labor Commission.
- Participate in drafting a separation or settlement agreement.
- Participate in consultation with management on HR issues.
- Prepare for and observe or participate in an unemployment benefits insurance appeal hearing.
- Review and discuss an ongoing employment law issue, such as a claim under Title VII, the Family Medical Leave Act, the Americans with Disabilities Act, or other substantive federal law or its state counterpart.
Environmental Law
Estate Planning
- Participate in drafting and reviewing any of the following:
- Wills.
- Revocable living trusts: tax planning.
- Revocable living trusts: non-tax planning.
- Revocable living trusts: generation skipping tax planning.
- Irrevocable trusts.
- Durable powers of attorney.
- Special powers of attorney for health care.
- Directives to physicians (living wills).
- Life insurance trusts.
- Transfer of ownership documents: quit-claim deeds.
- Transfer of ownership documents: assignments.
- Assist in gathering and organizing client information.
- Prepare diagrams of specific estate plans for clients.
- Prepare estate planning binders for clients.
- Prepare Crummey notices for life insurance trusts.
Family Law
- Review and discuss the Rules of Civil Procedure specific to Family Law.
- Understand the role of a Domestic Relations Commissioner. Meet as many commissioners as possible.
- Review Rule 26.
- Create a child support worksheet.
- Observe hearing on motion for temporary orders.
- Observe or participate in custody evaluation settlement conference if permission is granted.
- Participate in a collaborative law meeting if permission is granted.
- Participate in a mediation if permission is granted.
- Observe or participate in a family law trial.
- Participate in preparing a premarital agreement or review and discuss statutory requirements, case law, and necessary terms of premarital agreements.
Healthcare Law
HOA Law
- Draft bylaws and articles of incorporation.
- Draft Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs).
- Attend a board meeting.
- Draft an opinion letter to a board.
- Respond to a record request.
- Draft a letter to a homeowner.
- Review and become familiar with Utah Code Section 57-8a-101 et seq., Utah Code Section 57-8-1 et seq., and Utah Code Section 16-6a-101 et seq.
- Draft a Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&R) amendment.
- Draft a Rule or Resolution for an association.
- Prepare a ballot for association membership voting.
Immigration
- Observe or participate in an immigration related hearing.
- Discuss how the AILA website may be used as a tool in the area of immigration law.
- Participate in preparing and filing an I-129 Fiance(e) petition.
- Participate in preparing and filing an I-130/I-485 Petition for Alien Relative.
- Participate in preparing and filing an I-765 Application for Employment Authorization.
- Participate in client consultation and retention.
- Immigration Court Proceedings:
- Participate in client preparation for an Immigration Court hearing.
- Prepare the trial folder.
- Explore and navigate relevant legal authority (incl. CFR, INA, USC, Memos and Cables, Practice Manuals) and use available resources to remain current with Immigration Law (incl. AILALink, WestLaw, etc.
- Participate in a Master Calendar hearing.
- Participate in an Individual Merits Hearing; discuss.
- Draft various applicable motions (e.g. Motion to Reopen, Motion to Change Venue, Motion to Submit Evidence, etc).
- Draft substantial brief/memo to the Immigration Court (e.g. Eligibility Brief, etc)
- Immigration Benefits – USCIS:
o Draft forms such as G-28, I-765, N-400, etc.
o Prepare final petition packets to send to USCIS.
o Prepare client for CIS interview.
o Participate in a CIS interview.
o Draft substantial brief/memo to USCIS.
Detention/Bond:
- Participate in a visit to a client in jail (ICE Hold).
- Participate in communication with ICE/DRO to facilitate the setting of bond and release of an alien.
- Draft a Motion to Redetermine Bond.
- Participate in a bond hearing.
FOIA:
- Draft a FOIA request.
- Draft a FOIA appeal.
- Perform review of FOIA information received (analysis, TOC, summary).
Pro Bono/Volunteer:
- Participate in the Detained Calendar at Immigration Court.
- Participate in the Centro Hispano Pro Bono Clinic.
Miscellaneous:
- Attend AILA Chapter meetings and events.
Observe immigration intake, learn to spot issues.
Participate in Pro Bono Immigration Clinic.
Prepare immigration forms—basic petition and application for residency packet.
Observe or participate in immigration interview.
Observe or participate in immigration court hearing.
Prepare questions and review them with a client in removal proceedings prior to an individual hearing.
Observe and participate in an individual hearing.
Discuss when constitutional issues and otherwise inapplicable rules of evidence may come into play.
Discuss the appellate process following a determination by the immigration judge, and the applicable rules in the appellate courts.
Draft an appellate brief to the 10th Circuit.
Participate in a motion to suppress evidence and observe or participate in the hearing.
Juvenile Law
- Attend or participate in a shelter hearing.
- Attend or participate in a disposition hearing.
- Discuss the standards for removal with a Department of Child and Family Services (DCFS) worker.
- Discuss the role of a juvenile Guardian ad Litem; introduce where possible.
- In a Juvenile delinquency case, observe, participate in, or discuss:
- A detention hearing
- The role of a probation officer in detention cases
- An arraignment
- A pre-trial
- A trial
Legislative and Lobbying
Mergers and Acquisitions
- Help draft merger or asset purchase agreement.
- Draft corporate resolutions approving the transaction.
- Help draft a licensing agreement between the two entities.
- Help draft a supply agreement between the two parties.
- Participate in the due diligence process for mergers and acquisitions.
Municipal Law
- Attend and participate in a city council meeting.
- Attend and participate in a planning commission meeting.
- Draft an ordinance or resolution.
- Provide a written legal opinion on a municipal law matter.
- Draft an interlocal agreement with another governmental entity.
Negotiation
- Discuss how to prepare for the negotiation of a legal matter (e.g., release of a personal injury claim, lease agreement, etc.).
- Discuss when and how negotiation should be initiated.
- Discuss when and how to involve the client in negotiation.
- Discuss ethical and professional obligations of negotiators.
- Discuss skills needed to be an effective negotiator and how to acquire them.
Oil, Gas & Mining
- Draft Surface Use Agreement.
- Assist in preparing summary review of mineral leasing options.
- Review Abstract of Title for mineral ownership.
- Prepare memorandum regarding administrative regulation oil, gas and mining.
- Prepare Title Opinion.
- Prepare a Request for Agency Action.
- Draft an Opinion Letter.
- Participate in a Hearing before the Board of Oil, Gas and Mining.
Patent Law
- Observe or participate in a client interview.
- Participate in patent search/evaluation.
- Participate in drafting and filing a patent application.
- Participate in filing an Information Disclosure Statement (IDS).
- Discuss and review techniques for successful patent prosecution.
- Participate in a telephone conversation with an Examiner.
- Participate in drafting an Office Action response.
- Participate in preparing and drafting an appeal brief.
- Participate in patent litigation.
Personal Injury
- How to value a claim.
- How to negotiate with insurance providers.
- How to read medical reports.
- Drafting initial settlement offer.
- Who to sue.
- Draft discovery to opposing party.
- Answer discovery and produce responsive documents.
- Review and understand medical records.
- Gather medical records through HIPAA releases and subpoenas.
- Review and analysis of medical special damages.
- Prepare for deposition of adverse party.
- Retention of experts and compensation.
- Elevation of case & client communications.
- Accident investigation and documentation.
- Advise clients on risk management assessment.
Probate
- Prepare notice to creditors and arrange for publication.
- Prepare inventory of estate.
Prosecution
- Screen five different kinds of criminal cases and determine the charges to be filed.
- Discuss what should be done when a prosecutor declines to file charges requested be law enforcement.
- Participate in trial preparation.
- Discuss a prosecutor’s disclosure requirements under rule 16, URCrP, Brady requirements and other applicable discovery rules and law.
- Participate in a trial.
- Participate in an evidentiary hearing.
- Observe or participate in a plea negotiation.
- Participate in the interviewing of a witness or victim.
- Prepare for or participate in the preparation of jury instructions for a misdemeanor or a felony case.
- Prepare or review a Statement of Defendant to be used in entry of a guilty plea in both a misdemeanor and a felony case. Review and become familiar with Rule 11, URCrP.
- Review and understand Protective Orders; both civil protective orders under Chapter 7 of Title 78B and criminal protective orders under §77-36-2.5. Review the penalties for violations of both.
- Prepare a written response to a defense motion.
- Become familiar with the Crime Victims’ Bill of Rights, particularly a prosecutor’s responsibilities under the act. Prepare or review required notices to crime victims.
- “Ride along” with law enforcement; preferably at least four hours.
- Engage in a training discussion about the many different persons a prosecutor is likely to deal with in his or her official capacity.
- Discuss how to deal with “difficult” situations that are likely to arise between prosecutors and others with whom the prosecutor must deal.
- Discuss “DOs and DON’Ts” of maintaining good ongoing relations with others such as returning telephone calls and keeping other interested persons informed about matters.
- Train through discussion and case review how to screen for, recognize, and avoid conflicts of interest, either personal or official. Explain what actions should be taken if a conflict is suspected or identified.
Public Utilities
Real Estate Law
- Search a title at Recorder’s Office.
- Participate in drafting and reviewing any of the following:
- Real estate purchase agreements.
- Deeds of trust.
- Mortgages.
- Commercial leases.
- Residential leases.
- Notice of Default on the above.
Securities Law
- Review and revise any of the following documents:
- 10-K.
- 10-Q.
- Proxy Statement.
- 8-K.
- Registration Statement.
- Draft a PPM.
- Draft a complaint with securities fraud violations.
- Renew disclosures of an offering.
- Identify risks.
- Understand differences between Federal and Utah securities laws.
- Prepare Form 3,4,5 filings
- Participate in proxy drafting.
- Draft current report 8-K filings.
- Participate in 10-K and 10-Q filings
- Participate in bond offering memorandum drafting and associated due diligence.
- Public communications—review press releases for compliance with securities regulation.
- Transfer agent issues.
- Issuance of disclosure of restricted stock awards under equity incentive plan.
Tax Law
- Prepare and analyze tax calculations.
- Participate in preparing certain IRS tax forms, including the following:
- Form 2553 (S Corporation Election).
- Form 709 (Gift Tax Return).
- Form 706 (Estate Tax Return).
- Form 1041 (Income Tax for Trusts).
Trademark Law
- Observe or participate in a client interview.
- Participate in trademark search/evaluation.
- Participate in drafting and filing a trademark application.
- Participate in drafting an Office Action response.
- Participate in preparing and drafting an appeal brief.
- Discuss and review techniques for successful trademark prosecution.
- Participate in trademark litigation.
- Participate in drafting and filing a copyright application.
Water Law
